The Brookfield has two inner skirt chips, one about the size of a penny, the other a pinkynail, small open base bubble and a tiny flake on the wire ridge, has a neat piece of firebrick on the side. The Hemingray has a cool amber streak, 4 nicked drip points and two are whole but a bruise in the drip. Asking $55 for both and $12 for shipping. I can send more photos if needed.